“It’s better that we do it and tell them where [the weaknesses] are and how they can fix it, rather than find out the wrong way from a malicious attack,” he tells Professional Engineering.
The process involves mimicking the techniques used by aggressive nation states and cybercriminal groups such as Scattered Spider, which has been linked with attacks on major UK companies.
Hackers “don’t really care how many weaknesses you have across all of your systems; they just need to find a way in – and that’s often found through exploiting the interaction between humans and technology,” Arrowsmith says. This can mean using social engineering techniques such as phishing, tricking workers into revealing confidential information or doing things that compromise corporate security.
Also called ‘red teaming’, the method is just one way that Manchester-headquartered NCC Group aims to protect its global customers, including manufacturers, transport providers and energy companies, from the shadowy legion of anonymous online hackers.
For manufacturing and engineering firms, the effects of a hack can be severe. This issue is in particular focus in the UK following attacks on prominent organisations such as Jaguar Land Rover (JLR), where a “phased restart” is ongoing following a massively disruptive cyberattack on 1 September.
Claimed by a group known as Scattered Lapsus$ Hunters, which includes elements of Scattered Spider, it was revealed today (22 October) by the Cyber Monitoring Centre that the attack cost the country £1.9bn and affected more than 5,000 organisations, making it the “most economically damaging cyber event to hit the UK”.
Hacks on manufacturers can take so long to recover from because of the great care needed to prevent further damage, says Dray Agha, senior manager of security operations at cybersecurity firm Huntress. “A meticulous forensic investigation is essential to ensure all malicious tools are removed before restarting, preventing immediate reinfection. Complex production lines and supply chains must be brought back online in a slow, controlled sequence to ensure safety and stability,” he told Professional Engineering.
With severe potential consequences, it is vital that companies are able to fight back – and in offices around the country, steps are constantly being taken to enable just that.
Converging threats
Cyberattacks are an ever-present threat for engineering and manufacturing firms. The government’s 2024 Cyber Security Breaches Survey found that half of all businesses had identified breaches or attacks in the previous 12 months, rising to 62% of utilities and production businesses.
Many manufacturers are at risk because they use outdated production systems that were never designed to be connected to the internet and are “inherently insecure”, Agha says. Complex, interconnected supply chains also create multiple weak points that attackers can exploit.
Factories, energy facilities and other plants were previously segregated from the most at-risk systems, says Arrowsmith, who works with energy, water, manufacturing and transportation companies – but that has all changed with the advent of Industry 4.0 and greater digitalisation.
This integration of information technology and operational technology – also known as IT/OT convergence – has been happening for about 10 to 15 years, Arrowsmith says, but “it’s becoming quite critical now because the more you bring IT into OT and connect the two, [the more] you’re introducing internet-borne threats that OT systems were never designed to withstand”.
Speaking about UK industry, Arrowsmith continues: “Because OT drives physical processes, safety is the most critical risk you’re thinking about within OT environments, whereas in an IT environment, you’re generally worried about confidentiality, integrity and availability…
“What we’re seeing is people going on that journey and not necessarily having enough knowledge, perhaps, to bring those two teams together and drive security into those new environments that have been brought into the IT space through convergence.”
The window for OT upgrades is often a lot smaller than in IT, he adds. “To patch a vulnerability, they’d potentially have to take the plant down,” he says, talking about the generic challenges faced by manufacturers. “To do that costs money, and therefore they only do that twice a year – whereas in IT we’re patching once a week.”
Incident response
The recent JLR hack will have changed the mood in industry, Arrowsmith says. “These incidents do drive higher-level scrutiny and awareness across boards of directors,” he says. “They will definitely be going and asking questions of their operations as to: ‘What if that was us?’
“The one thing that we always drill people about is that it’s not a question of if, it’s a question of when. So therefore you need to think about how prepared you are for when it does happen – and just don’t underestimate how quickly it happens and how quickly it changes, and how stressful, and the amount of pressure it will put your staff and operators under.”
One key necessity the company stresses is having a well-rehearsed incident response plan, making sure everyone knows what role they have when an attack happens. Regular training is also “really important” to drive awareness of the risks, Arrowsmith says.
Despite the IT/OT convergence, there are still ways to maintain separation between systems. The Purdue model, for example, can introduce layers between IT systems and devices on the shop floor.
“If [a hacker] comes in at the top and is in enterprise IT, you want to make it really, really difficult to get down to the stuff that could cause something catastrophic in an industrial environment, in a smelting plant or in an energy substation or something like that. Having a layered, defensible architecture for your systems, going right down to your OT if the two are converged, is really important.”
The UK Cyber Security and Resilience Bill is expected to go through parliament in the coming months, aimed at strengthening defences against cyberattacks, giving regulators new powers and requiring increased incident reporting. It is not just hackers that companies need to be aware of, however, as shown by the Amazon Web Services (AWS) outage earlier this week. That incident would have likely affected the corporate side of most industrial organisations, Arrowsmith says, due to widespread use of cloud services – and that could soon extend to OT management and control as well.
“Let’s learn from what’s happened in the past and make sure we build resilience into that design and network, to make sure that if a large giant like AWS falls over, or the CrowdStrike incident that happened a year ago… what resilience do you have in terms of backup to bring systems back up into play?
“It comes back to the planning, and making sure that you’ve thought these things through and done sufficient planning to mitigate the issue.”
Want the best engineering stories delivered straight to your inbox? The Professional Engineering newsletter gives you vital updates on the most cutting-edge engineering and exciting new job opportunities. To sign up, click here.
Content published by Professional Engineering does not necessarily represent the views of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers.