This is something the government wants to change. Last month, it announced £40m in funding for eight new Robotics Adoption Hubs, designed to help businesses understand how robots could improve their operations and give them the expertise to introduce them. The hubs will cover everything from manufacturing to agriculture, recycling and surgery.
More money is always helpful but it is not a panacea for the broader problem of adoption, according to experts. “We’ve been very successful at developing new concepts, technologies and so on,” says Mike Wilson, chief automation officer at the Manufacturing Technology Centre (MTC) and visiting professor of robotics and automation at Loughborough University. “But where we’ve failed – and I think this is true across the board, but it’s very true in robotics – is we have struggled to help get that technology into industry.”
Part of that is down to cash. The UK has a good pedigree of funding university research, but is notoriously poor at turning promising academic projects into commercial businesses. That matters because of the gap in technology readiness levels (TRLs), which are used to assess how close a technology is to being ready for practical use. Research funding will often take a technology to around TRL 5, but manufacturers need something closer to TRL 8 or 9, where a system has been demonstrated to work reliably and is ready for deployment.
Financial incentives to move up the levels are not always obvious. Building a robot takes considerably more time and money than building software, something the MTC is trying to help fix.
Beyond that issue, the UK’s robotics research has focused on agriculture, construction and infrastructure robots, rather than traditional factory automation. There has been less focus on massive industrial robots because British factories tend to specialise in producing relatively small numbers of high-value products, rather than the enormous production lines seen elsewhere. The scale of manufacturing businesses – 95% of which are small and medium-sized enterprises, according to Wilson – also compounds issues.
A ‘make do and mend’ mindset can also stifle new developments. “In the UK we’re very proud that we keep all of our old machines running, whereas in Germany they’re very proud they bought new ones,” Wilson says.
The government’s new adoption hubs are intended to tackle some of those barriers by providing demonstrations, training and advice to businesses considering robotics. Wilson welcomes the investment, but questions whether it goes far enough. Only about half of the hubs have a manufacturing-related focus, he says, while others are directed at sectors such as healthcare and agriculture.
There are geographical gaps, too, including in the West Midlands – one of Britain’s most important manufacturing regions. “£40m sounds like a lot of money, but it isn’t really, and it can get spread quite thinly very quickly,” Wilson says.
For Robert Richardson, a robotics researcher at the University of Leeds and co-founder of Acuity Robotics, the adoption hubs are a welcome development. But he argues that the government also needs to think about something else: where Britain's robots come from. “We can’t rely on robots from overseas,” he says.
Richardson points to China’s success building a domestic robotics industry, which he argues has come from sustained investment in the technology and the supply chains needed to support it. China has coordinated investment across the whole supply chain, including the smallest components needed in robotics, rather than encouraging companies to buy more finished machines. The UK has not taken that approach, and Richardson says that could make it increasingly dependent on overseas manufacturers.
With domestic technology, Richardson says, “we know it’s been built to meet our needs… We know where its data goes.”
He believes there is time to change things. AI could help in the design and iteration processes that turn an idea into a finished product. Wilson also thinks AI will be beneficial.
Both are optimistic the government’s intervention will help – but they also recognise that the hubs alone are not enough. Building a more productive manufacturing sector needs sustained investment, better support for commercialising British research and a willingness among manufacturers to change how they work. “This isn’t the answer,” says Wilson. “It’s the start of the answer.”
Want the best engineering stories delivered straight to your inbox? The Professional Engineering newsletter gives you vital updates on the most cutting-edge engineering and exciting new job opportunities. To sign up, click here.
Content published by Professional Engineering does not necessarily represent the views of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers.